#atom

Contrasting approaches to motivation based on positive empowerment versus negative urgency

Core Idea: White Hat and Black Hat Gamification represent opposite approaches to motivation, with White Hat focusing on meaning, accomplishment, and creativity (positive empowerment), while Black Hat relies on scarcity, unpredictability, and avoidance (negative urgency).

Key Elements

• White Hat Gamification

  • Utilizes Core Drives at the top of the Octalysis Framework:
    • Core Drive 1: Epic Meaning & Calling
    • Core Drive 2: Development & Accomplishment
    • Core Drive 3: Empowerment of Creativity & Feedback
  • Creates a sense of meaning, fulfillment, and expression
  • Provides long-term engagement and positive emotions
  • Examples: Wikipedia contributions, creative platforms, skill development applications
  • Users feel good during and after the experience

• Black Hat Gamification

  • Utilizes Core Drives at the bottom of the Octalysis Framework:
    • Core Drive 6: Scarcity & Impatience
    • Core Drive 7: Unpredictability & Curiosity
    • Core Drive 8: Loss & Avoidance
  • Creates urgency, obsession, and addictive behaviors
  • Highly effective for short-term engagement and metrics
  • Examples: Limited-time offers, gambling mechanics, fear of missing out (FOMO)
  • Users often feel anxiety, obsession, or addiction

• Ethical considerations

  • Black Hat techniques aren't inherently unethical - they can be used positively
  • Many health and productivity apps use Black Hat techniques to encourage positive behaviors
  • The ethics depend on the intention and ultimate outcome for the user
  • Sustainable systems typically balance both approaches

• Application patterns

  • Zynga games heavily relied on Black Hat techniques, leading to high initial engagement but eventual user burnout
  • Many educational platforms use White Hat techniques to create meaningful learning experiences
  • Most successful products combine both approaches strategically
  • Facebook uses both: White Hat for content creation and sharing, Black Hat for notifications and FOMO

Additional Connections

• Broader Context: Ethical Game Design (considerations when applying these techniques)
• Applications: Habit Formation (how these techniques can build or break habits)
• See Also: Intrinsic vs Extrinsic Motivation (related but distinct concept in motivation design)

References

1. Chou, Y. (n.d.). Actionable Gamification: Beyond Points, Badges, and Leaderboards.
2. Ethics of gamification discussed in Chapter 14 of Actionable Gamification.

#gamification #motivation-design #behavioral-psychology #ethics #user-experience

Connections:

Sources:

• From: Chou-Actionable Gamification