#atom

Techniques for unwinding problematic code abstractions

Core Idea: When faced with an inappropriate abstraction, the most effective approach is to inline the code, remove conditionals, and allow new, more appropriate abstractions to emerge.

Key Elements

• Bad abstractions often manifest as shared code with many parameters and conditionals
• Recovery requires temporarily reintroducing duplication to understand true requirements
• The process eliminates incorrect abstractions without losing functionality
• This approach prioritizes clarity and maintainability over preserving existing structure
• The technique facilitates discovery of more appropriate abstractions

Recovery Methodology

1. Inline the Abstraction

   • Copy the entire abstracted code back into each caller
   • Preserve all functionality during this step
   • This creates intentional duplication

2. Simplify Each Instance

   • Within each caller, identify which parts of the inlined code are actually used
   • Use parameter values to determine relevant code paths
   • Remove code that isn't needed in each specific case
   • Replace parameter-based conditionals with direct code

3. Observe the Results

   • Examine the simplified code in each caller
   • Look for true patterns that emerge across instances
   • Identify genuine commonalities vs. superficial similarities

4. Create New Abstractions

   • Extract truly common code into new, more focused abstractions
   • Ensure new abstractions represent single, coherent concepts
   • Avoid forcing code to fit if it doesn't naturally belong together

Benefits

• Eliminates complicated conditional logic
• Improves readability by making each code path explicit
• Makes future changes easier by avoiding inappropriate coupling
• Reveals the true nature of the problem being solved
• Provides a clean slate for better design decisions

Connections

• Related Concepts: The Wrong Abstraction (the problem being addressed), Duplication vs Abstraction (the philosophical foundation), Sunk Cost Fallacy in Programming (psychological barrier to overcome)
• Broader Context: Code Refactoring Patterns (broader set of techniques), Technical Debt Reduction (strategic goal)
• Applications: Legacy Code Maintenance (common scenario requiring this technique)

References

1. Metz, Sandi. "The Wrong Abstraction." Blog post. Originally from Chainline Newsletter.
2. Metz, Sandi. RailsConf 2014 "All the Little Things" talk.

#programming #refactoring #software_design #code_maintenance

Connections:

Sources:

• From: Article The Wrong Abstraction