Approaches to gathering feedback and validating game design decisions
Core Idea: Playtesting is a critical process in game development where designers observe players interacting with the game to identify strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities for improvement through different testing methodologies.
Key Elements
Types of Playtesting
- Self-testing: Designer plays their own game, useful for initial concept validation
- Internal testing: Testing with the design team or close associates
- Blind testing: Observers watch new players learn and play without assistance
- Directed testing: Focused on specific game elements or mechanics
- Digital testing: Using Tabletop Simulator for Game Design or similar platforms
- Physical testing: Using printed or fabricated components
Playtesting Cycle
- Prepare prototype (physical or digital)
- Define testing objectives and questions
- Recruit appropriate playtesters
- Conduct the playtest session
- Gather feedback through observation and questions
- Analyze results and identify issues
- Implement changes using Rapid Game Prototyping Workflow
- Repeat with updated prototype
Digital vs. Physical Testing
-
Digital Advantages:
- Easier to coordinate remote testers
- Faster implementation of changes
- Lower cost for component production
- Easier data collection and analysis
-
Physical Advantages:
- More authentic tactile experience
- Better for testing physical components
- No technology barriers for testers
- May reveal physical usability issues
Feedback Collection Methods
- Observation during play
- Post-game questionnaires
- Guided discussions
- Think-aloud protocols
- Recorded sessions for later analysis
- Metrics collection (win rates, play times, etc.)
Additional Connections
- Broader Context: Game Design Process (where playtesting fits in development)
- Applications: Iterative Design (using playtesting to drive iterations)
- See Also: User Research Methods (related approaches from UX design)
References
- TBLOPcraft tutorial on rapid prototyping and playtesting
- Various game design books and resources on playtesting methodologies
#gamedesign #playtesting #feedback #iterativedesign #userresearch
Connections:
Sources: